Rating Your Website – the Most Important Question
What do You Think of My Website?
This is probably the question I get asked the most. It’s a hard question to answer for two reasons. First, because people have often put a lot of time and energy and thought and care into the development of their website. They want to hear positive feedback, but as a professional, they don’t hire me to be warm and fuzzy – they want a website that works. Secondly, and more important, because I can’t tell from looking at their website whether it meets the most important criteria of succces for a website:
Does it Meet Your Business Objectives?
In other words, does it do what it’s intended to do? Which is the most important question of all in rating the ultimate success of your website.
Websites can be a source of good feelings, pride, visual appeal, professional image, and more. But, above all, they must move your business forward.
You may need your website to do one (or many) of the following:
- Lead Generation – getting potential customers interested enough that they will contact you, or providing enough value that they will give you their contact information
- Closing Sales – actually getting people to buy something (usually a product) from your website
- Building your Brand – being an effective representative of your unique differentiator and value proposition in the marketplace, bringing people back, starting a conversation or an online buzz
- Internal Tools – letting your clients / distributors / suppliers / employees / franchisees log in to a secure area where they can conduct company business from anywhere easily and efficiently
- Stakeholder Communications – especially for public companies and franchisors, this may mean providing a great deal of information in a well organized, easy to navigate, easy to update structure
Ideally, you don’t want your website trying to do all five of the above. You need to know which one is the key to growing your business, and then orient your website around that particular goal, because each goal has different tactics, strategies, content and workflow management that will make it the most effective.
Trying It Out
I highly recommend determining what you are trying to do with your website, and how it will help your business grow. Then take a look at your website from that point of view.
If you are trying to generate leads, go to the website as if you’ve never been there before. Remember that most users will spend only seconds deciding whether your website fits their needs and feels right to them before either leaving to look elsewhere, or deciding to go a little further. Would you, as someone who doesn’t know your company at all, want to spent time on this site? Does it answer the key questions:
- What do you do?
- Why should I care?
- What’s in it for me?
If not, you will lose a large percentage of people right away.
Next, look at the website and see whether you have an appealing offer of value in exchange for people’s contact information. If your site is to generate leads, the most important thing it can do is get people either contacting you directly (which takes effort on their part) or leaving you their information so you can contact them. What value are you offering that would lead them to provide this information? Be creative about what you can do. Make sure you have clear calls to action, and an EASY way for people to sign up. Look at the trade-offs between asking for a lot of information (will your customers be hesitant to provide too much detail) vs getting more people’s contact information but with less detail. Would you want to sign up on the site?
Next Steps
Obviously, we can keep going here, but I’m sure you get the picture. The other easy way to decide whether your website is a success is metrics. Are you getting the number of leads you want from your site? If not, then to be blunt, the site is not working. At that point, you may want to get in touch with Open Box and we can work together so you know that your website IS contributing to the success of your business. At that point, you won’t care what I think of your website, because you’ll know that the people it was built for think it’s great.

